A tree in Spain sparked some debate about the possibility of Spanish having travelled New Zealand before Cook and rightly won a mention in The Spanish Helmet.

The tree in question is a large pohutukawa that the locals believe to be 400-500 years old. That would fit in well with a discovery by Francisco de Hoces in 1526, don’t you think?

The original Landcare Research press release about the tree can be found here: http://www.landcareresearch.co.nz/news/release.asp?Ne_ID=33Since I don’t trust NZ government agencies to adequately maintain a permanent URL, I am archiving a copy of this release herewith:

Famous tree sparks debate on discovery of New Zealand

Media Release: Thursday, 20 September 2001

A pöhutukawa tree at ´the end of the world´ has stirred up debate on whether the Spanish were the first Europeans to reach New Zealand, ahead of the Dutch and the British.

 

Dr Warwick Harris – and an intriguing pöhutukawa tree on the other side of the world

The giant pöhutukawa is a big attraction in the Spanish north-west coastal city of La Corunna, capital of the province of Galicia. This province was thought until the time of Columbus to be at the end of the world.

La Corunna’s mayor has chosen the tree as the city’s floral emblem, and many locals believe it to be 400 to 500 years old. However, because the tree is a New Zealand native, this could mean that the Spanish sailed to New Zealand before Captain James Cook in 1769, or Abel Tasman in 1642. A Spanish helmet found in Wellington harbour about 1880 is one clue that the Spanish were here earlier.

Landcare Research botanist Dr Warwick Harris has recently returned to New Zealand after a tour that included an invitation to talk about New Zealand native plants in La Corunna. He caused a flurry of local media coverage when he stated his belief that the tree could not be more than 200 years old.

“No-one knows exactly how the tree got to La Corunna, and it has not been scientifically aged.

“However, I have the romantic idea that it was brought into Spain by the British during the Napoleonic wars and can be linked to the heroic story of Sir John Moore.”

Moore took a small British army into Spain in 1808 to check the French invasion, but was forced to make a strategic retreat over mountains, pursued by Bonaparte himself and a huge army. Nevertheless, the British mission saved Spain from full occupation by the French. Moore eventually led his men more than 400 kilometres to La Corunna where British ships were waiting, but in the last phase of the evacuation his arm was blown off by a French cannon. He saw the end of the battle and died, and his hurried burial was immortalised in a famous poem by Sir Charles Wolfe.

Dr Harris says the history relating to Moore indicates it is likely there was a British garrison in La Corunna in the early 1800s. “At some stage the British must have recovered Moore’s body, and laid him in a tomb in what is now the Garden of San Carlos, created in 1834. Most likely there was a British involvement in the creation of the garden, and it is a romantic thought that the pohutukawa came to La Corunna at that time.

“We know that Captain Cook brought back plants from his first voyage to New Zealand, and within ten years there was commerce in those plants in England. We don’t know about pöhutukawa specifically, but we do know that the British were largely responsible for introducing New Zealand plants to Europe.”

Links to Christchurch

Dr Harris says the mayor of La Corunna, Dr Francisco Vasquez, is interested in forming a sister relationship with Christchurch, its antipodal city.

“If you drilled a hole through the earth from Christchurch, the nearest city you’d come out at is La Corunna.

“So the famous pöhutukawa is about as far away from home as it could possibly get.”

Pöhutukawa quite at home in Spain

While pöhutukawa struggle in some parts of New Zealand, Dr Harris says they thrive in the coastal regions of Galicia.

“Pöhutukawa there are not subjected to possums. The frost-free conditions in coastal areas suit them nicely. New Zealand cabbage trees are also common in La Corunna, as are flaxes.

“There’s actually some concern that New Zealand plants might become invasive, as have Australian Eucalypts, which create a fire risk.

“But as Galicia regularly has very dry summers, our natives probably wouldn’t spread from where they are planted to survive in the wild.”

The article was reprinted on Scoop: http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/SC0109/S00020.htm
and was reported on in this NZ Herald piece: http://www.nzherald.co.nz/nz/news/article.cfm?c_id=1&objectid=218169

500 Years Old or 200 Years Old?

The argument put forward in the release is that the tree is probably only 200 years old and that it came to Spain via the British.

In my mind, there should be a relatively simple (and harmless to the tree) technique to take a core ring sample or something to find out how old the tree is. Mabye a botanist or arborist could tell me about this?